Villain in this hand has been playing with me for the past 5 hours or so. He has been playing somewhat tighter than the average player at these games and doesn't raise preflop much at all. He seems like a relatively ABC player and a regular in this cardroom. He is probably 50 and definitely plays as a hobby but doesn't seem incompetent.
UTG+1 (loose semi-whale with $400) limps, MP ($250) limps, Hero limps button with 57s, Villain (BB with $1100) raises to $30, limpers call, Hero calls ($1500).
My range for Villain raising out of the BB is extremely tight. Likely hes raising 77+, AQ+, maybe AJ or KQ. I think I've seen him raise 1 time from blinds so far in past 5 hours.
Flop ($120) 8c5d5h
Villain (BB) checks, UTG+1 bets $30, MP calls, Hero raises to $105, Villain plays with his chips for about 30 seconds and then raises to $305, folds to Hero?
I start to play with my chips and count out the $200 extra and start shuffling chips and after 30 seconds Villain says "I will tell you that you are way behind right now". I really can't see how Villain ever has a 5 here as there are literally no 5s that he raises with preflop out of the blinds, even a hand like A5s. So basically he either has 88 and flopped a full house or is overplaying an overpair.
Is this a puke fold or what do you guys think?